How to Respond to an Offer on Your Home: Accept, Counter or Decline
What You’ll Learn
- How to read an offer beyond the price, from financing to contingencies and what conveys
- What accepting an offer generally means, and what to check before you sign
- Why a counter generally voids the original offer, and what you can counter besides price
- When declining or letting an offer expire may make sense
- How buyer-agent compensation requests and Fair Housing rules fit into your response
When a buyer makes an offer on your home, you generally have three ways to respond: accept, counter or decline. Each choice has different effects on the deal, and the right one depends on the whole offer, not just the price at the top of the page.
This article covers the single-offer decision: how to read one offer, what each response generally does, and what besides price you can negotiate. If you're weighing several offers at once, see how to read multiple offers beyond the top number. If an offer includes an escalation clause, escalation clauses, explained walks through how they work. Contract rules vary by state and by the forms used where you live, so treat this as general education and lean on your real estate agent, and a real estate attorney where your state requires or you want one, for how it applies to you.
First, Read the Whole Offer, Not Just the Price
An offer is a package of terms. Two offers at the same price can lead to very different outcomes once you look at the details. Before you decide how to respond, review:
- Price and earnest money. The earnest money deposit shows the buyer's commitment and is handled as the contract says. For how deposits work and when they may be refunded, see earnest money, explained.
- Financing. Is the buyer paying cash or using a loan, and what type? Is there a preapproval letter? The difference between pre-qualified and pre-approved matters here.
- Contingencies and their deadlines. Inspection, appraisal, financing, and sometimes the sale of the buyer's current home. Shorter or fewer contingencies can mean fewer ways for the deal to change later. Real estate contingencies, explained covers each one.
- Closing date and possession. When the buyer wants to close, and when you'd hand over the keys.
- Credits and concessions. Requests for help with the buyer's closing costs or other seller-paid items.
- What conveys. Appliances, fixtures, window treatments or other items the buyer expects to stay with the home.
- The response deadline. Many offers say how long you have to respond before the offer expires.

Option 1: Accepting the Offer as Written
Accepting means you agree to the buyer's terms exactly as they were offered. In most transactions, that's done by signing the offer within its deadline and delivering your acceptance in the way the contract or your state's practice requires. Once acceptance is properly made and communicated, you're generally under contract, and the contract's terms and deadlines start to run.
Before you sign, it helps to estimate what you'd actually walk away with at that price, after your loan payoff, closing costs and any credits the buyer asked for. Seller closing costs: how to estimate your net proceeds shows how to build that number. For what happens after you sign, see what sellers should expect between offer and closing.
Acceptance can make sense when the price and terms already fit your goals, the buyer's financing looks solid, and the timeline works for your move. Accepting doesn't mean the deal can't change. Contingencies may still give the buyer options later, such as after the inspection or appraisal.
Option 2: Countering the Offer
A counteroffer is your response with different terms. Under general contract principles, a counteroffer does two things at once: it turns down the original offer and puts a new one on the table. The Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School describes a counteroffer as one that rejects the original and voids it, so the original offer can no longer be accepted. NAR's consumer guide to navigating multiple offers makes the same practical point: after a counter goes out, the seller generally loses the option of signing the buyer's first offer.
How this plays out in your transaction depends on your state's law and the contract forms used where you live. Some forms treat small changes differently, and some states use specific counteroffer forms. Ask your real estate agent how counters work locally, and talk with a real estate attorney if you have questions about whether, or when, a contract has been formed.

What you can counter besides price
Many sellers think of a counter as a price number. In practice, you can propose changes to almost any term, such as:
- The closing date, or a short period after closing before you move out, if your contract forms allow it
- The amount of earnest money
- The length of the inspection, appraisal or financing contingency periods
- The amount of any closing cost credit the buyer requested
- Which appliances or other items stay with the home
- How repairs will be handled, such as selling the home in its current condition
Sometimes the most useful counter accepts the buyer's price and changes a term that matters more to you, such as timing. For how credits fit into a sale, see seller concessions and when they help.
Set a clear deadline
A counter usually includes its own time limit for the buyer to respond. Maine's real estate commission, for example, advises in its guidelines on offers and counteroffers that a written counter name a set window for the buyer to accept it. A clear deadline keeps the negotiation moving and tells everyone when the counter expires.
Expect a few rounds
The buyer can accept your counter, decline it or send a counter back. Negotiations can go several rounds. Each new counter generally replaces the last one, so be sure you know which version is actually on the table. Keep track of every change, and read the final version in full before anyone signs.
Keep everything in writing
Verbal agreements on price or terms can lead to misunderstandings, and under the general principle known as the statute of frauds, contracts for the sale of land are among those that typically must be in writing and signed to be enforced. The same Maine guidelines recommend putting offers and counters on paper, and handling any withdrawal of a written offer or counter on paper as well. They also note a seller may withdraw a counter in writing before it's accepted. Rules on withdrawals and timing vary by state and contract, so confirm the process before you rely on it.

Option 3: Declining the Offer
You can decline an offer outright, or in some cases simply let it expire at its deadline. Declining can make sense when the price and terms are far from where you need them, or when the buyer's financing or timeline doesn't fit your plans.
Declining doesn't have to end the conversation. Some sellers decline but let the buyer know they'd consider a new offer. Others counter instead, even when an offer is low, because a counter keeps a dialogue open. Neither approach promises a better result. A low offer can also be useful information: if several buyers come in well under your asking price, it may be worth revisiting your pricing. Price reductions: when and how covers that decision.
What Your Decision Can't Be Based On
You have wide room to decide which terms work for you, but not to decide based on who the buyer is. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, HUD explains that it is illegal to discriminate in the sale of housing because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or disability. Many state and local laws add more protected characteristics.
The practical rule: compare offers on their terms, such as price, financing, contingencies and timing. Leave personal details about the buyer out of the decision. If something in an offer gives you pause, ask your real estate agent before you respond.

The Insider View: Countering Isn't Automatically the Strong Move
Countering can feel like the savvy choice, as if accepting a first offer leaves money behind. Sometimes it does. But a counter also carries risk. Because it generally voids the original offer, the buyer is free to walk away instead of answering, and NAR's consumer guide notes that a buyer who feels their offer was already fair may start looking at other homes.
A few patterns experienced sellers watch for:
- Countering every term. Changing the price, the dates, the credit and the contingencies all at once can stall a negotiation. Prioritizing one or two terms often keeps things moving.
- Chasing price while ignoring terms. A slightly lower price with solid financing and fewer contingencies may be worth more to you than a higher number with more ways for the deal to change.
- Forgetting the second negotiation. Many deals involve another round after the inspection. How you handle that round is covered in how sellers should handle repair requests.
- Letting deadlines slide. Missing a response deadline can mean an offer expires. Know the deadline on every offer and counter.
None of these is a rule. They're reasons to decide what matters most to you before you respond, rather than countering by reflex.
Buyer-Agent Compensation and Credits in an Offer
Some offers ask the seller to pay part or all of the buyer's agent compensation, or to give a credit toward the buyer's costs. According to NAR's summary of its settlement practice changes, which took effect Aug. 17, 2024, agent compensation remains "fully negotiable." Offers of compensation between agents can no longer appear on MLS platforms, but a seller may still make such an offer outside the MLS, and may offer buyer concessions such as help with closing costs.
In practice, a request like this is one more term in the offer. Like any other term, you can accept it, counter it or decline it. How it shows up in your contract and on your closing statement depends on the agreements involved, so ask your real estate agent to explain it and include it in your net proceeds estimate.
Questions to Ask Before You Respond
- When does this offer expire, and how must my response be delivered?
- After my loan payoff, closing costs and any credits, what would I net at this price?
- What financing is the buyer using, and what does the preapproval say?
- Which contingencies are included, and how long does each one last?
- Do the closing date and move-out timing work for my plans?
- If I counter, which one or two terms matter most to me?
- Does anything in the offer raise a legal question I should take to a real estate attorney?

Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to respond to an offer?
It depends on the offer. Many offers state a deadline, and the offer may expire if you don't respond by then. There's no single national rule, so check the offer itself and ask your real estate agent.
If I counter, can I still accept the original offer later?
Generally, no. Under general contract principles, a counteroffer rejects and voids the original offer. The buyer would need to make that offer again. How this applies depends on your state's law and contract forms, so ask a real estate attorney if it matters in your situation.
Can I counter more than one buyer at a time?
That situation raises its own risks, including the chance of more than one acceptance. How it's handled varies by state and by the forms used. See multiple offers, and talk with your real estate agent and a real estate attorney before sending more than one counter.
Can a buyer back out after I accept?
It depends on the contract. Contingencies may let a buyer cancel under certain conditions within set deadlines, and what happens to the earnest money depends on the contract terms.
Do I have to pay the buyer's agent?
Agent compensation is negotiable. If an offer asks you to pay some or all of the buyer's agent compensation, that's a term you can accept, counter or decline, like any other term in the offer.
The Bottom Line
Every offer gives you the same three choices: accept, counter or decline. Read the full offer before you choose, know what you'd net, and decide which terms matter most to you. A counter generally voids the original offer, so use it on purpose. Keep every round in writing, watch the deadlines, and base your decision on the terms, never on who the buyer is.
This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Contract formation, counteroffer rules and contract forms vary by state, and your contract's wording controls. Talk with your real estate agent, and with a real estate attorney where your state requires one or for advice about your specific situation. Advice4Homeownership is a publisher, not a real estate brokerage or law firm.

